Which of the following should not be done by a notary when presented with a fraudulent document?

When a notary encounters a fraudulent document, it is critical that they uphold the integrity of the notarization process. Completing the notarization under duress is fundamentally inappropriate because it compromises the ethical duties of the notary. Notaries are required to perform their duties without coercion and to ensure that all aspects of the notarization are legitimate and in accordance with the law. Notarization is intended to provide an assurance of authenticity and voluntary action; thus, participating in a transaction under duress undermines the validity of the notarization and can lead to legal consequences.

In contrast, documenting the request for verification, notifying the parties involved, and ensuring the identity of the signer are all actions that a notary should take to maintain transparency and protect against fraud. Each of these actions helps to establish a record of the circumstances surrounding the request and ultimately supports the trustworthiness of the notarial process. Therefore, the only action that should be avoided in this scenario is completing the notarization while under duress, as it violates the notary's responsibility to perform their duties freely and without pressure.